In Supreme Court abortion case, the past could be the future

  • Supreme Court to listen to Mississippi abortion case subsequent week
  • U.S. abortion rights could return to pre-1973 situations
  • Mississippi girl, 72, displays on her long-ago abortion

OXFORD, Miss., Nov 23 (Reuters) – Just months earlier than she was set to start out regulation faculty in the summer time of 1973, Barbara Phillips was shocked to be taught she was pregnant.

Then 24, she needed an abortion. The U.S. Supreme Court had legalized abortion nationwide months earlier with its landmark Roe v. Wade ruling recognizing a lady’s constitutional proper to terminate a being pregnant. But abortions weren’t legally out there at the time in Mississippi, the place she lived in the small city of Port Gibson.

Phillips, a Black girl enmeshed in the civil rights motion, could really feel her dream of turning into a lawyer slipping away.

Register now for FREE limitless entry to

“It was devastating. I was desperate,” Phillips stated, sitting on the patio of her cozy one-story home in Oxford, a school city about 160 miles (260 km) north of Jackson, Mississippi’s capital.

At the time of the Roe ruling, 46 of the 50 U.S. states had some kind of felony prohibitions on abortion. Access usually was restricted to rich and well-connected ladies, who tended to be white.

With a feminist group’s assist, Phillips positioned a health care provider in New York prepared to offer an abortion. New York earlier than Roe was the solely state that permit out-of-state ladies acquire abortions. She flew there for the process.

Now 72, Phillips doesn’t remorse her abortion. She went on to attend Northwestern regulation faculty in Chicago and notice her aim of turning into a civil rights lawyer, with a protracted profession. Years later, she had a son when she felt the time was proper.

“I was determined to decide for myself what I wanted to do with my life and my body,” Phillips stated.

U.S. abortion rights are below assault in contrast to any time since the Roe ruling, with Republican-backed restrictions being handed in quite a few states. The Supreme Court on Dec. 1 is ready to listen to arguments in a case wherein Mississippi is searching for to revive its regulation, blocked by decrease courts, banning abortion after 15 weeks of being pregnant. Mississippi has raised the stakes by explicitly askingthe court docket, which has a 6-3 conservative majority, to overturn Roe v. Wade.

Such a ruling could flip again the clock in Mississippi, which at the moment has only one abortion clinic, and different states to the form of setting on abortion entry that Phillips skilled practically a half century in the past.

Large swathes of America could return to an period wherein ladies who need to finish a being pregnant face the selection of present process a probably harmful unlawful abortion, touring lengthy distances to a state the place the process stays authorized and out there or shopping for abortion tablets on-line.

Mississippi’s abortion regulation is just not the just one being examined at the Supreme Court. The justices on Nov. 1 heard arguments in challenges to a Texas regulation banning abortion at about six weeks of being pregnant, however haven’t but dominated.


Mississippi is one in all a dozen states with so-called set off legal guidelines that might instantly ban abortion in all or most circumstances if Roe is overturned, in response to the Guttmacher Institute, a analysis group that helps abortion rights.

Many are in the South, so a Mississippi girl would be unable to acquire an abortion in neighboring Louisiana, Arkansas, Tennessee or Alabama. The nearest states the place abortion would stay authorized, not less than in the quick time period, would be Illinois and Florida.

The common distance a Mississippi girl would wish to drive to succeed in a clinic would improve from 78 miles to 380 miles (125 to 610 km) every means, in response to Guttmacher.

While some abortion rights advocates worry a return to grisly unlawful back-alley abortions, there was an vital growth since the pre-Roe period: abortion tablets. Mississippi is amongst 19 states imposing restrictions on medication-induced abortions.

Mississippi officers are cagey on what a post-Roe world may appear to be. Republican Attorney General Lynn Fitch, who requested the court docket to overturn Roe, declined an interview request, as did Republican Governor Tate Reeves.

Mississippi Commissioner of Agriculture and Commerce Andy Gipson, who as a Republican state legislator helped shepherd the 2018 passage of the 15-week ban, known as Roe v. Wade “antiquated, old law based on antiquated and old science.”

Gipson in an interview declined to reply questions on what Mississippi – or the southeastern United States – would be like with out abortion rights, specializing in the specifics of the 15-week ban.

“It’s a false narrative to paint this as a picture of an outright ban throughout the southeast,” Gipson stated, noting that the Supreme Court doesn’t should formally overturn Roe to uphold Mississippi’s regulation.

In court docket papers, Fitch stated scientific advances, together with contested claims {that a} fetus can detect ache early in a being pregnant, emphasize how Roe and a subsequent 1992 determination that reaffirmed abortion rights are “decades out of date.”

Abortion rights advocates have stated any ruling upholding Mississippi’s regulation would successfully intestine Roe, giving states unfettered energy to restrict or ban the process.

Phillips worries a couple of revival of harmful, unregulated abortions that imperil ladies’s lives.

“I’m afraid that many more women and girls will be in back alleys,” Phillips stated. “I’m worried we are going to find them in country roads, dead.”

Register now for FREE limitless entry to
Reporting by Lawrence Hurley; Editing by Will Dunham and Scott Malone

REUTERS/Karen Pulfer Focht

Barbara Phillips, who in 1973 had to fly to New York to receive an abortion, speaks with a reporter in Oxford, Mississippi, U.S., October 26, 2021. Picture taken October 26, 2021.  REUTERS/Karen Pulfer Focht

Barbara Phillips, who in 1973 had to fly to New York to receive an abortion, speaks with a reporter in Oxford, Mississippi, U.S., October 26, 2021. Picture taken October 26, 2021. REUTERS/Karen Pulfer Focht